Remember “Occupy Wall Street?” More currently, “Black Lives Matter?” And the latest example, “Women’s March?” They have this much in common:
- Loose Organization
- Diverse Membership
- Aggregate Complaints
- Unfocused Intentions
- Non-Specific Proposals
- Outdoor Meetings
- Catchy Names
“Occupy Wall Street” was pretty much just news items about their encampment. “Black Lives Matter” fails to note that Federal statistics show that 80-90% of murdered “black lives that matter” are victims of black killers. Half of all murder victims, nationally, are black; blacks are less than 15% of the population. Where is that protest and call to action?
In the context of this protest, do they mean “Black, Mexican, Muslim, LGBTQ, Women’s Lives Matter?” Or do they mean “Black, Young, Men’s Lives Matter,” but this just happens to be a women’s march? Just what do they mean?
It seems that the “Women’s March” was all about disappointment, fear, and frustration transformed into pink anger. Disappointment that Hillary did not win, fear that women’s rights will be undermined, and frustration that women do not receive equal pay.
Trump became the effigy to blame for everything.
Misogyny: How many participants, do you think, could cite specific instances when President Trump recently disrespected women who were not attacking him? Where is the acknowledgement of the nonchalant treatment of wives and women by iconic presidents such as JFK, and Bill Clinton?
If the marchers are promoting equality for women, his business organizations reflect great respect for women by hiring them, promoting them into management and paying them well; sounds like equality to me. Why not ask women who work for the Trump organization how they feel about their misogynist boss?
Immigration: First, Trump got trapped in the “Newspeak” of the way we use “immigrant.” Many foreign nationals, from many countries, apply for visas, “green cards,” and citizenship every year. Those who gain permanent residence or citizenship can rightly be called immigrants. A great number of Americans are immigrants or children of immigrants.
The proponents of unlimited immigration and aligned journalists fought to not use the legal term “alien.” They insisted on substituting “______-immigrant” until it became commonplace. The problem is that non-hyphenated, legal immigrants heard these “_______-immigrants” being criticized and threatened, and felt included in that group; they took personally the anger, fear, and distain.
By verbally lumping the “_______-immigrants” together with immigrant citizens, they built support for their open-borders philosophy. If we had stuck with “aliens,” and “foreign nationals,” the citizens would not have felt combined with them.
Exactly, what did he say about Mexicans? Not just the clips, the whole statements. He said that among the illegal migrants were, drug smugglers, human traffickers, fugitive criminals, including murders, and rapists. Is that true? Yes. Trump’s opponents extracted this description and implied that he meant ALL Mexicans fit these profiles.
Muslims: Trump wants to limit and vet prospective refugees entering the US from Islamist countries tied to terrorism. He wants Muslim communities to help identify and thwart jihadist terrorists.
Women who live in Muslim countries might not be sympathetic with the complaints of the marchers; certainly, they would or could not march on their capitals protesting. Why not ask Muslim-American women what they would face if they went home to Arabia and Africa? What would you face going there as a Christian? Count your blessings that you live here in America.
There are no government proposals or actions right now that threaten women; he just took office Friday. All the rhetoric is about what could happen; what rights they fear might be lost; what affronts they fear they may face. Fear is a factor, but not fact
The one thing that stands out to me is concern about reversing Roe v. Wade. I understand opposition to abortion challenges. I support safe, informed, reasoned choice for every woman. So, focus on defending that right or you risk people writing you off as generally disappointed with the election results, and righteously irritated at the challenges of being a woman.
The last point is this: What do you propose, aside from replacing Donald Trump? Many commentators have shrugged their shoulders about the purposes of the march because the marchers are not clear about what they are championing. It was a shame that all the time, money, effort, and commitment it took to get people on the streets ended in a fog of vague purposes.