When the same company of actors performs one play badly, will a new play make them perform better? The political establishment’s senior leaders of the Democratic Party must believe it can happen.
We watched the “critics” close the old DNC play in November of 2016, after an eight-year run. Trouble was, the cast were only part of the problem; the writers, producers and directors were the rest. Now we have the preview of the new DNC play, which plans to run from now until 2018. Trouble is, the same people plan to produce the show.
Nancy Pelosi, from California, is House Democratic leader. She published an op-ed article in the Washington Post 7/23/17.
In her editorial, she outlined the proposed new party agenda: (To paraphrase,) “Make America Better Again,” or maybe, “Have I Got a Better Deal for You!” It seems to be a leftish echo of Donald Trump’s winning, campaign platform, which put control of the White House, and the Congress in the hands of the Republican party. How can adopting similar positions help Democrats win?
She berates the GOP for not …” creating good-paying jobs, or rebuilding America’s crumbling infrastructure, or advancing tax reform, Republicans have spent six months trying to raise Americans’ health costs to fund tax breaks for billionaires.” That sad, tired rhetoric has not worked at all so far.
I do not know what Ms. Pelosi expected in six months. How much of those goals happened in the four years the Democrats had control of the White House, Senate, and the House of Representatives, or the following four years they controlled both the White House and Senate? But, politics is a short-term memory profession.
The Democrats took the first year and two months of Obama’s presidency to create the Affordable Care Act, starting one month after President Obama’s first inauguration, and ending thirteen months later. I guess we will have to give President Trump at least four years to measure progress on healthcare, tax reform, infrastructure, immigration, and job creation.
Meanwhile, the Democrats promise to offer Americans “A Better Deal: Better Jobs, Better Wages, Better Future.” The San Francisco Democrat complained, “Working people from the heartland to the cities are struggling in a rigged economy and a system stacked against them.” Why do we have these problems after fifteen years of her political leadership?
She also wrote of a renewed, “…commitment to the hard-working men and women across the United States who have been left out and left behind for too long.” I wonder how much time Ms. Pelosi spends in the “heartland,” schmoozing with the “hard-working men and women?”
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. wrote an op-ed article for the New York Times, and gave interviews to describe the new ideas of the “better deal.” Here is the gist. (Note: the first clue to the truth is denial of it. Look for what they say is “not.”)
“Our better deal is not about expanding the government, (n)or moving our party in one direction or another along the political spectrum. Nor is it about tearing down government agencies that work, that effectively protect consumers and promote the health and well-being of the country,”
“It’s about reorienting government to work on behalf of people and families.” (Whatever that means. “We are from the government, and we are here to help you.?”)
“Week after week, month after month, we’re going to roll out specific pieces here that are quite different than the Democratic Party you heard in the past,” Schumer said. “We were too cautious. We were too namby-pamby.”
The Democrats say their agenda targets “old-fashioned capitalism.”
The leaders of the Democrats in Congress offer a “new-more-better” deal to Americans. Specific promises:
- Ten million, new, fulltime, good-paying jobs in the next five years. Tax credits for employers who hire and train workers at a good wage, apprenticeships, and on-the-job training.
- Break the grips of big business special interests, monopolies, on rising living prices.
- Lower the cost of prescription drugs, regulate pharma price increases, allow Medicare/Medicaid to negotiate drug prices.
Other ideas in the mix:
- Single-payer healthcare system
- $15 minimum wage
- One-trillion-dollar infrastructure plan
Okay? That is the new DNC agenda? How would this approach, delivered by these people, align the disparate viewpoints of the left? Who would feel energized by adopting these goals? What jobs are not filled that need apprentices and trainees? How much is “good-paying?” Inflation is below 2%; which costs are rising, besides healthcare insurance? What is missing from our current anti-trust laws? Where have price controls worked without reducing supply or creating black markets? Why limit negotiation of prices to drugs? Why not other costs? What if Trump does these things before the Democrats do?
I can see the faint ghost of Bernie Sanders’ populism in the language, but very faint. It seems to be an establishment effort to ignite and unify the Democrats under the present leadership. The dissonance and vagueness of the agenda strikes me as an unfocused attempt at cat herding. It reminds me of that definition: “repeating the same actions and expecting different results is insanity.”